Can the following groups of elements be classified as Dobereiner's triad?
$(a)$ $Na, Si, Cl$
$(b)$ $Be, Mg, Ca$
Atomic mass of $Be = 9, Na = 23, Mg = 24, Si = 28, Cl = 35, Ca = 40$. Explain by giving reasons.

Vedclass pdf generator app on play store
Vedclass iOS app on app store
(B) No,because these elements do not possess similar chemical properties,which is a fundamental requirement for Dobereiner's triads,even though the atomic mass of silicon $(28)$ is approximately the average of the atomic masses of sodium $(23)$ and chlorine $(35)$,i.e.,$(23 + 35) / 2 = 29$.
$(b)$ Yes,because these elements belong to the same group (alkaline earth metals) and exhibit similar chemical properties. Furthermore,the atomic mass of magnesium $(24)$ is the average of the atomic masses of beryllium $(9)$ and calcium $(40)$,i.e.,$(9 + 40) / 2 = 24.5$,which is very close to $24$.

Explore More

Similar Questions

An element $X$,which is a yellow solid at room temperature,shows catenation and allotropy. $X$ forms two oxides which are also formed during the thermal decomposition of ferrous sulphate crystals and are major air pollutants.
$(a)$ What would be the nature (acidic/basic) of the oxides formed?
$(b)$ Locate the position of the element in the Modern Periodic Table.

Arrange the following elements in the order of their increasing nonmetallic character:
$Li, O, C, Be, F$

Arrange the following elements in the order of their decreasing metallic character:
$Na, Si, Cl, Mg, Al$

Which of the following are the characteristics of isotopes of an element?
$(i)$ Isotopes of an element have same atomic masses
$(ii)$ Isotopes of an element have same atomic number
$(iii)$ Isotopes of an element show same physical properties
$(iv)$ Isotopes of an element show same chemical properties

Which of the following elements does not lose an electron easily?

Vedclass Products

For Students

Vedclass Test Series

Mock tests in real JEE/NEET style with performance analysis. 5-day free trial.

Start Free Trial
For Teachers

Exam Paper Generator

Generate Set A/B/C/D exam papers from 7.5L+ questions in 2 minutes. 3 chapters free.

Try Free
For Institutes

Online Exam Module

Live online exams with unlimited students, 360° analytics & white-label branding.

See Demo